The Emotional Impact of Perfectionism: Striving vs. Obsessing

By Shannon Bussnick, LSW

Perfectionism is often misunderstood, packaged neatly into rigid definitions that don’t fully capture its complexity. Many associate it with the textbook “Type A” personality—someone with a spotless house, a relentless work ethic, and an eye for every last detail. But perfectionism is far more nuanced, manifesting in ways that are deeply personal, shaped by individual values, experiences, and internal narratives.

Who Defines Perfectionism?

Perfectionism is, at its core, a subjective pursuit. What one person sees as “perfect” may be entirely different from another’s standards. Society tends to define perfectionism through productivity, organization, and control, reinforcing its association with type A traits. However, a broader lens reveals that perfectionism can be about emotional labor, social etiquette, preparedness, or even the way one carries themselves in social spaces. Some define it through aesthetics, others through performance, and some through relationships—always striving to be the “perfect” friend, partner, or parent.

Perfectionism as Perceived Superiority vs. Internal Compulsion

Is perfectionism a pursuit of superiority, or is it driven by fear of being seen as lacking? This distinction is crucial. Some perfectionists are internally motivated (self-oriented perfectionism), while others are externally driven (socially prescribed perfectionism). In many cases, it’s not about seeking superiority but about avoiding perceived failure or rejection.

For some, perfectionism looks like being early and staying late, having everything one might need on hand, greeting everyone in the room with warmth, and exiting with the utmost respect. Others feel the need to re-read their work countless times, keep their environment meticulously maintained, or anticipate every possible problem in advance. The drive for perfection doesn’t always come from the same place, nor does it always lead to the same outcome.

Does Perfectionism Always Lead to Compulsions?

Not necessarily. While perfectionism can be linked to obsessive-compulsive tendencies, it doesn’t always lead to distress or dysfunction. It can exist as a personality trait—one that drives people toward high standards without becoming a burden. However, perfectionism does have a known correlation with anxiety, procrastination, imposter syndrome, and self-criticism. If left unchecked, it can be self-destructive rather than motivating.

Can Perfectionism Ever Be Healthy?

Yes, in balance. “Adaptive perfectionism” exists—a form that drives excellence without the weight of self-punishment. An artist refining their craft with deep satisfaction rather than self-loathing, or a doctor double-checking their work to ensure accuracy without spiraling into distress, are examples of constructive perfectionism. The key is distinguishing high standards from unrealistic expectations.

A Spectrum, Not a One-Size-Fits-All Label

Rather than treating perfectionism as a binary “healthy vs. unhealthy” trait, it may be more helpful to place it on a continuum. Here are some ways to frame its manifestations:

• Striving vs. Obsessing – Is the person aiming high with flexibility, or are they rigid and distressed?
• Conscientious vs. Self-Critical – Are high standards motivating, or are they a source of shame?
• Disciplined vs. Fear-Driven – Is the pursuit of excellence about passion, or about avoiding failure?
• Refinement vs. Paralysis – Does attention to detail enhance work, or does it prevent completion?

Educating on the Spectrum of Perfectionism

To inform and educate, we must challenge the notion that perfectionism only looks like ultra-organized behavior. A person with “messy perfectionism” might procrastinate because they fear not doing something perfectly. Another might over-apologize in social situations, fearing they said something “wrong.” Normalizing conversations around perfectionism’s emotional toll—especially in high-achieving cultures—can help individuals recognize when it is working for them and when it is working against them.

Final Thoughts

Perfectionism is deeply personal. It can be an incredible driver of ambition, but it can also be a source of immense pressure. Recognizing where one falls on the spectrum is the first step toward making it a tool rather than a tormentor. Perhaps, instead of chasing “perfection,” the real goal is to redefine what excellence means on an individual level—free from the constraints of external expectations.

Let us know in the comments: Where do you see yourself on the perfectionism spectrum?

---